
At first glance, A Case of Life and Limb flirts with being a touch too charming—almost verging on twee—but Sally Smith’s elegant prose and finely tuned atmosphere soon win you over. Set in the hushed, snow-covered halls of the Inner Temple in the winter of 1901, this mystery blossoms into something more substantial than its genteel surface might suggest.
Gabriel Ward KC, with his measured intelligence and quiet tenacity, makes for a compelling central figure. His partnership with Constable Wright offers a nice balance of legal insight and police procedural, but it’s the interplay between the mystery and the intricate world of class, tradition, and privilege in the Temple that gives the novel its satisfying texture.
The central conceit—a mummified hand arriving by post, followed by a series of increasingly sinister packages—is both intriguing and macabre. While the final resolution may be a touch predictable for seasoned mystery readers, the journey there is rich with historical detail, sharp dialogue, and a tightly woven plot.
Ultimately, this is a polished and thoughtful mystery—graceful rather than groundbreaking, but all the better for it. A strong start to what one hopes will be a continuing series featuring the quietly brilliant Gabriel Ward.