Ann Cleeves delivers another atmospheric and intricately plotted mystery in The Killing Stones, set against the hauntingly beautiful backdrop of Orkney. The setting is a true standout—windswept, wild, and richly layered with history. From archaeological intrigue to local folklore, Cleeves weaves cultural detail into the story in a way that feels immersive and authentic.
Jimmy Perez and Willow are compelling leads, both familiar and evolving, and it’s a pleasure to watch them navigate not just the investigation, but also their life together and their connection to the island community. The emotional stakes feel grounded, especially as the case becomes personal for Perez, following the murder of his old friend Archie Stout.
The mystery itself is packed with misdirection and a steady drip of clues, keeping me guessing throughout. That said, the final twist felt slightly abrupt—less like a puzzle piece clicking into place and more like a sudden swerve. While it didn’t entirely undermine the narrative, it did leave the resolution feeling a touch disconnected from the carefully laid groundwork.
Still, Cleeves’ mastery of mood, character, and place makes this a satisfying and evocative read. The Killing Stones may not have the most seamless ending, but it more than makes up for it with its atmosphere, character depth, and the promise of more to come. Looking forward to the next installment.